Well, well, well...there is something that can overpower the allure of all-you-can-eat breadsticks and salad: unlimited rolls and habit-forming butter. After seven years of Olive Garden being named America's favorite for casual dining, a new establishment with 23 locations in Michigan has risen to the top.

RELATED: Big Lots 'Reopening' 5 Stores in Michigan

According to new numbers from Technomic (a fancy name for people who count restaurant stuff), Texas Roadhouse and its nearly addictive cinnamon butter brought the heat with a whopping 14.7% jump in sales, totaling $5.5 billion in 2024, which was good enough to knock an Italian juggernaut off its pedestal.

America's New Favorite Casual Dining Options Presence in Michigan

The dining area of a causal restaurant is seen with a NEW starburst and a stamp reading CUSTOMER FAVORITE are seen as well as an outline of Michigan.
Canva
loading...

There's a reason why Michiganders don't mind driving long distances for good food. We'll drive an hour or more for a worthy entree. Some might be willing to log the miles for Texas Roadhouse's cinnamon butter and rolls (seriously, what do they put in that stuff?). The Mitten State boasts 23 locations, and yes, there's even one in the Upper Peninsula.

According to The Independent, Texas Roadhouse's prices haven't skyrocketed like other casual dining chains, making it an affordable option for families.

What Happened to Olive Garden's Dominance in Michigan?

The inside of an italian restaurant with several diners and a server delivering a meal to a table. An outline of Michigan is seen in the lower right.
Canva
loading...

So what happened to Olive Garden, the former number-one casual dining establishment for seven years? Price. That's it, plain and simple. Despite having 27 locations in Michigan, Olive Garden's affordability has left it with fewer casual diners in an era where our willingness to leave our houses for food is countered by our ability (and desire) to order in.

RELATED: Walmart No Longer Michigan’s Top Retailer: Who’s The New #1?

Curious about which restaurants round out America's Top 10 for casual dining? Keep scrolling.

America's Favorite Casual Dining Restaurants: Top 10

Technomic, a restaurant consulting firm, recently analyzed sales data from 2024 to determine which casual dining restaurant was the USA's #1 choice. Here's a look at the list and how many locations each has in Michigan in America's Favorite Casual Dining Restaurants: Top 10 list.

Gallery Credit: Scott Clow

 

More From 99.1 WFMK